Oh what a night!

On Friday, October 19, 2007 a group of wine lovers met up at Cafe de Paris in Columbia, MD to say farewell to old friends and welcome in new (check back soon for a full review of the restaurant). The theme of the event: “Big Reds”. Completely vague, this led to a very interesting assortment of wines from around the world. Although putting together flights was quite a challenge, Newsguy (the celebrated man of the evening) did an excellent job. The event was my first time meeting up with the group but I feel confident in saying it wasn’t my last! Kim and I had an amazing time and look forward to future events.

Without further ado, here are my notes from the evening. I did not include the notes for the NV Cafe de Paris Cuvee which was slightly watered down and did not leave a lasting impression. Oh what a night!

1990 Charles Heidsieck Brut Blanc de Blancs Champagne Blanc des Millénaires: The nose on this thing was incredible. Very nutty with subtle melon and grapefruit. The wine literally made me smile upon tasting it…it was that good. The palette had explosions of elegannt fruit and such great texture. It was very refreshing into the finish that left me searching for another splash. My rating: 96 pts.

1995 Boizel Brut Champagne Joyau de France - I opened the first bottle and was surprised by the lack of a “pop”, concerned the bottle had been compromised. The second followed the same suit and both were good with consistent notes. A lot of ripe fruits but a little tight. I would expect this to get better over the next 5 or so years. I’d give this 90 pts with hope that it would develop nicely. My rating: 90 pts

Final Notes: The Blanc des Millénaires was incredible. The best Champagne I can remember having and definitely drinking quite nicely. I think the Boizel was a little young but definitely saw some potential in it. Winner here was an easy one: Blanc des Millénaires

Round 1:
2001 Le Macchiole Bolgheri Superiore Paleo (100% Cab Franc): The nose on this wine was wonderful and complex. I noted berry fruits, mineral, saw dust, carrot, amazingly unique! Great structure and balance with solid fruits and a creamy texture. Lovely wine. My rating: 95 pts

1998 Domaine du Vieux Télégraphe Châteauneuf-du-Pape La Crau: I got a lot of unique notes on this one as well. Cajun spice, red pepper, herbs, plum, boysenberry, gentle tannins with a subtle, lasting finish. This gets my vote for the most interesting wine of the night - I really had a lot of fun with it. My rating: 92 pts

1998 Brancaia Il Blu (Sangiovese with Merlot and Cab Sauv): Raspberry, dark fruits, floral nose. Mild acidity with soft tannins and quite a long finish. My rating: 92 pts

Round 2:
2001 Hanna Bismark Mountain Noir: Elegant nose of raspberry, sweet french oak, green pepper and a touch of tomato, which was interesting in a good way. As the wine developed in the glass it became “dark and serious” as pointed out by newsguy. We agreed the French oak fell off fast but the wine maintained great balance. My rating: 90 pts

1996 Flora Springs Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley St. Rutherford Vineyard: Cigar box, cedar, currant nose. The fruits were alive and came in layers while the tannins soft and elegant. I agree that this wine was overshadowed by the other two in the flight, but I felt that overall it was the most balanced of the bunch. My rating: 94 pts

1999 Fatboy Cabernet Behrens & Hitchcock: HUGE. I could leave it at that, but I’ll continue. This Fatboy lives up to its name. Big nose of dark cherry, blackberry and butter with a touch of thyme. The wine attacked my palette with big fruits and mouth drying tannins. Overall great balance and integration - was amazing with the lamb (as pointed out by Mrs. Jace!). What I want out of a big cab - My rating: 93 pts

Round 3:
2001 Sette Ponti Oreno Great color to this wine. Great fruits on the nose with mineral and smokey oak. Huge body with good balance and velvety tannins to match. The finish was incredibly long but fell apart a bit early. My rating: 91 pts

2003 Numanthia-Termes Toro Numanthia A first for me (Numanthia) but will not be the last. The wine had a deep, dark color with a big bouquet of fruits and earth. The wine started off complex and developed very nicely on the palette. Maybe a bit young or just needed a few more hours in the decanter? Regardless, exceptional wine that may be better in 5 years. My rating: 92 pts

2001 Casa Lapostolle Clos Apalta Colchagua Valley Spicy, dark fruit and anise on the nose with a touch of tar. Big wine that moves with elegance and grace across the palette, reminding me again on the finish of it’s great depth. My rating: 91 pts

Round 4: (warning: at this point my notes became less detailed and often a mere “good fruit, elegant…yum” or “this is fun”, but I feel confident in my overall impressions)
2002 Viader Napa Valley Worried this would be young, I was pleasantly surprised. The wine was not sharp at all and had a good structure and soft tannins. I noted the usual dark fruits, buttered toast, and a touch of herb that came in layers with a drop of cocoa on the finish. I gave this one 91 pts…Kim rated it much higher at 95 pts. My rating: 91 pts

1999 Dalla Valle Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon Creamy nose with good dark cherry and raspberry and chocolate. All I have beyond that is “WOW…one of the best tonight, 94 pts.” I wish I had more to say! I know of the three, this had the longest, most exciting finish. I’ll stick with My rating: 94 pts.

1999 Viader Napa Valley This was more young than the 2002 and a bit more wound up. I agree that it needs a few more years but can see this becoming as good as, if not better than, the 2002. Similar fruit notes to the 2002. My rating: 91 pts.

My Wines of the Night:
1990 Charles Hiedsieck
1996 Flora Springs Cabernet
2001 Le Macchiole Bolgheri Superiore Paleo
1999 Dalla Valle